GasolímetroRoad trip fuel cost calculator

95 or 98 octane petrol: is it worth paying more?

Updated 12 November 2026 · By Indomit Studio

If your car’s handbook asks for 95-octane petrol, filling up with 98 won’t give you more power or a saving that pays for itself: in Spain it currently costs about 16 cents more per litre at the same filling station. It only makes sense if the manufacturer requires it, and even where 98 is merely recommended, the fuel you save rarely covers the price difference.

The short answer

  • Check the handbook or the label inside the fuel flap: it gives the minimum octane the engine needs.
  • If it says 95, 98 brings no measurable benefit. If it “recommends” 98, the average measured gain was 2.7% in fuel economy; to cover the price you’d need 9%.
  • In Spain, 98 currently costs about 16 cents more per litre at the same station, 10% more: at 15,000 km (9,300 miles) a year, about €170 extra.
  • If you fill up with the wrong one, nothing serious happens: there’s no need to drain the tank.

What octane is (and isn’t)

Octane measures how well petrol resists igniting on its own under compression before the spark fires, known as knock or pinking. It doesn’t measure energy content: a litre of 98 holds no more “power” than a litre of 95. In Spain, all petrol must have at least 95 RON and 85 MON (Royal Decree 61/2006); 98 is petrol with more headroom against knock.

That headroom only helps if the engine uses it. High-compression or turbocharged engines can advance the ignition timing on higher-octane fuel and perform a little better; according to fueleconomy.gov, in these engines higher-octane fuel improves performance and fuel economy. An engine designed for 95 does nothing different on 98. According to Germany’s ADAC, today’s car engines are designed for 98 octane at most, so 100-octane “premium” fuels don’t help most of them either.

What tests have found

In 2016, the American motoring club AAA tested cars with four-, six- and eight-cylinder engines designed for regular petrol on a chassis dynamometer, using regular and premium fuel. It found no significant gains in power, fuel economy or emissions.

In 2017 it repeated the test with cars that recommended premium fuel without requiring it, under demanding conditions: towing, carrying loads and hard acceleration. Fuel economy improved by 2.7% on average, from 1% worse in an Audi A3 to 7.1% better in a Cadillac Escalade, and power by 1.4%. AAA’s conclusion: the gain doesn’t offset the higher price of premium, and drivers are unlikely to notice anything in normal town or open-road driving. In the US, octane is quoted on a different scale and the numbers don’t match ours, but the comparison is the same: regular against premium.

fueleconomy.gov comes to the same view: in most cars, higher octane may slightly improve fuel economy in severe use, such as towing or carrying heavy loads in hot weather, but in normal driving the benefit is little or none, and the extra cost is usually higher than the saving.

The numbers: what 98 costs per year

Take the calculator’s typical petrol family hatchback, rated at 6.0 L/100 km WLTP and using about 7.2 in real life. We compare a year’s fuel on 95, on 98 at the same consumption, and on 98 if it used 2.7% less, AAA’s average gain in cars that recommend premium.

Annual petrol spend for a family hatchback by mileage
Km per yearOn 95On 98, same consumptionOn 98 using 2.7% less
10,000 km€1,124€1,237 (+€113)€1,204 (+€80)
15,000 km€1,686€1,855 (+€170)€1,805 (+€119)
20,000 km€2,248€2,474 (+€226)€2,407 (+€159)
Values from the calculator’s model: real-world consumption = 6.0 L/100 km WLTP × average gap of +20% (European Commission, COM(2024) 122). Unleaded 95 at €1.561/L, Spanish national average on 20 November 2026; 98 at 16 cents more, the average difference across the 5,501 stations that sell both (Geoportal de Gasolineras). 2.7% saving: AAA (2017) average in cars that recommend premium, measured under demanding conditions. 10,000 km ≈ 6,200 miles.

Even with AAA’s saving, 98 works out about €119 dearer at 15,000 km a year. To break even, the car would have to use 9% less on 98, more than the best result in the test (7.1%). The national average for 98 is higher still, €1.758/L, because the stations that sell it are, on average, slightly dearer.

What about additives?

Many 98 or “premium” petrols contain cleaning additives. According to ADAC, whether they have a positive effect is “extremely hard to verify”, and in practice it’s probably small. Its conclusion: standard fuel is always enough; premium does no harm, you just pay more.

Tips

  • Use the octane your handbook gives. If it says “95” or “95 minimum”, there’s no reason to pay more.
  • If it says 98 is required (some sports cars and high-compression or turbocharged engines), always use it: on lower octane the engine retards the ignition to protect itself and loses power and efficiency.
  • If 98 is only recommended, 95 is fine day to day. 98 may help slightly with heavy loads, towing or heat, but it doesn’t pay for itself.
  • If you put 95 in a car that needs 98, the knock sensor adapts. In very old cars without one, avoid working the engine hard (top speed, hills, towing) until you fill up with the right fuel.
  • If you want to use less fuel, speed, tyre pressure and load matter far more than octane: fuel consumption by motorway speed and tyre pressure and fuel consumption.
  • For a trip cost, the calculator uses the price of 95; if you fill up with 98, enter your station’s price instead.

Frequently asked questions

Does a car use less fuel on 98 octane?

Not measurably if it’s designed for 95: AAA found no gains. In cars that recommend premium it measured 2.7% less on average under demanding conditions, which doesn’t make up for paying 10% more per litre.

What happens if I put 95 in a car that needs 98?

In a modern car, the knock sensor adapts and you can keep driving; there’s no need to drain the tank. You’ll lose a little power until you fill up with 98 again. In very old cars without a knock sensor, drive gently until you can refuel.

Can I mix 95 and 98 petrol?

Yes. According to ADAC, putting 98 in a car that takes 95 has no downside other than having paid more, and putting 95 in one that needs 98 doesn’t mean draining the tank either.

Sources

More guides

See all guides →