Car, train or plane: which is cheaper for a trip?
Updated 12 November 2026 · By Indomit Studio
It depends mostly on how many of you there are. A train or plane ticket is paid per person; the car’s fuel is shared between everyone in it. From Madrid to Valencia, a family hatchback’s petrol costs about €44 and the average high-speed train fare is €27.04: alone, the train is a little cheaper; with two people, the car already wins.
The short answer
- Travelling alone, the high-speed train costs on average the same as or less than the car’s fuel on almost all the main routes from Madrid.
- With two or more people, the car is almost always cheaper, because the fuel is shared and tickets aren’t.
- Between train and plane, most travellers on the main routes from Madrid choose the train: even on Madrid–Barcelona, where its share is lowest, it’s 83.1% (CNMC).
- Also count tolls, parking and getting to the station or airport, and the time each option takes.
The numbers by route
We compare a family hatchback’s petrol with the average price paid for a high-speed train ticket in 2025, according to Spain’s competition authority, the CNMC. It’s an average of all tickets sold: book early and you’ll find cheaper ones; at the last minute, dearer ones.
| Route | Distance | Car (petrol) | Car, per person (2) | Car, per person (4) | Train, per person |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Madrid–Barcelona | 618 km | €76 | €38 | €19 | €52.89 |
| Madrid–Valencia | 357 km | €44 | €22 | €11 | €27.04 |
| Madrid–Seville | 533 km | €66 | €33 | €16 | €38.41 |
| Madrid–Málaga | 529 km | €65 | €33 | €16 | €37.61 |
| Madrid–Alicante | 421 km | €52 | €26 | €13 | €31.34 |
| Madrid–Zaragoza | 313 km | €39 | €19 | €10 | €41.57 |
Travelling alone, the average train fare costs less than the petrol on Madrid–Barcelona, Madrid–Valencia, Madrid–Seville, Madrid–Málaga and Madrid–Alicante. With two people, the car already wins on every route. With four, the gap is wide: Madrid to Barcelona works out at about €19 each by car against €52.89 by train.
The CNMC reaches a similar view with its own model, which adds up the money and time of each option: on Madrid–Valencia, with four people, the car is far more competitive than the train; on Madrid–Barcelona, because of the distance, the train still wins even with four. Bear in mind that many operators sell very cheap children’s tickets: according to the CNMC, AVLO sells them at €5 for under-14s on several routes, and OUIGO at €7 for ages 4 to 13.
What the fare doesn’t show
- Car: the table only counts fuel, as the CNMC does in its model. If you pay tolls or parking at your destination, add them: see toll motorway or free road. Tyre wear and servicing also rise with distance; what each kilometre really costs is in cost per km of a car.
- Train and plane: add getting to and from the station or airport at both ends, and whatever you need to get around there. The CNMC assumes in its model that you arrive 25–35 minutes early for the train and 60 for the plane.
- Time: by car you go door to door, but you’re driving; on the train you can work or rest. That’s why, according to the CNMC, most business travellers choose the train while leisure travellers lean more towards the car.
- Plane: fares vary a lot with the date and how far ahead you book. Check whether luggage is included and compare the final price.
And emissions
According to the European Environment Agency, the train is the most efficient form of motorised passenger transport per passenger-kilometre, and planes and cars the least efficient. By car, emissions per person fall the more of you there are: a full car emits far less per passenger than one with a single occupant.
Tips
- Work out the fuel for your exact route with the calculator, which uses the real distance and your car, and divide it between you.
- Check train or plane fares for your dates: the table uses averages.
- If there are two or more of you and you don’t mind driving, the car is usually cheapest; if you’re alone and the train drops you close by, compare carefully before taking the car.
- If you share a car, split fuel and tolls fairly: how to split fuel costs on a road trip.
- To use less fuel on the road, watch your speed: fuel consumption by motorway speed.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, the car or the train?
Travelling alone, Spain’s high-speed train costs on average the same as or less than the petrol on most main routes from Madrid. With two or more people, the car is usually cheaper, because the fuel is shared and tickets are per person.
How much does a high-speed train ticket from Madrid to Barcelona cost on average?
According to the CNMC, the average high-speed fare on Madrid–Barcelona was €52.89 in 2025. That’s the average of all tickets sold: booking early can be cheaper.
How much does the petrol cost from Madrid to Valencia?
About €44 in a petrol family hatchback, for 357 km by road, at current prices and with no tolls. For your own car, use the calculator.
Sources
- CNMC (17-7-2026), La alta velocidad duplicó los viajeros y redujo los precios más de un 40 % desde la liberalización
- CNMC (2026), Informe sobre la competitividad del modo ferroviario (INF/DTSP/269/25)
- European Environment Agency (2021), Rail and waterborne — best for low-carbon motorised transport
- OSRM — Open Source Routing Machine (distancias por carretera)
- European Commission (2024), COM(2024) 122 — real-world CO₂ emissions
- Ministerio para la Transición Ecológica — Geoportal de Gasolineras (precios medios nacionales)